| | | Elizabeth City St. 23, Catawba 21 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:24 |
| C | 2-11 | C19 | End of 1st half, clock 00:00. |
| C | 1-10 | C20 | Tm rush for loss of 1 yard to the CAT19. |
| C | 1-10 | C20 | CATAWBA drive start at 00:24 (2nd). |
| | | Daniel Mendez kickoff 61 yards to the CAT9, T.Landrum return 11 yards to the CAT20 (Preston Duarte;J Marable). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 41 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| | | Elizabeth City St. 23, Catawba 21 |
| E | 4-4 | C18 | Daniel Mendez field goal attempt from 35 GOOD, clock 00:30. |
| E | 4-4 | C18 | Timeout Catawba, clock 00:35. |
| E | 4-4 | C18 | Timeout Elizabeth City St., clock 00:35. |
| E | 3-4 | C18 | Curtis Rich pass incomplete to Dexter Manley (C.Noel). |
| E | 2-3 | C17 | Curtis Rich rush to the CAT19, fumble by Curtis Rich recovered by ECSU Dennis Hamilton at CAT18. |
| E | 1-10 | C24 | Curtis Rich pass complete to Dexter Manley for 7 yards to the CAT17, out-of-bounds (B.Vennable). |
| E | 3-10 | C41 | Curtis Rich pass complete to Ricky Hill for 17 yards to the CAT24, 1ST DOWN ECSU (C.McAfee). |
| E | 3-10 | C41 | Timeout Elizabeth City St., clock 01:34. |
| E | 2-10 | C41 | Curtis Rich pass incomplete to Tashawn Lee, QB hurry by M.Fair. |
| E | 1-10 | C41 | Curtis Rich pass incomplete to Bryan Fields. |
| E | 1-10 | E41 | Curtis Rich pass complete to Tashawn Lee for 18 yards to the CAT41, 1ST DOWN ECSU (T.Jones). |
| E | 1-10 | E41 | ELIZABETH CITY ST. drive start at 01:55 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:07 |
| C | 4-11 | C24 | T.Trexler punt 35 yards to the ECSU41, out-of-bounds. |
| C | 3-11 | C24 | H.Williamson pass incomplete to A.Strong (Justin Hamilton). |
| C | 2-11 | C24 | H.Williamson pass incomplete to A.Hall. |
| C | 2-1 | C34 | H.Williamson pass incomplete to P.Brooks, PENALTY CAT holding 10 yards to the CAT24, NO PLAY. |
| C | 1-10 | C25 | H.Williamson rush for 9 yards to the CAT34 (Derrick Downey). |
| C | 1-10 | C25 | CATAWBA drive start at 03:02 (2nd). |
| | | Daniel Mendez kickoff 54 yards to the CAT16, T.Landrum return 9 yards to the CAT25 (Zavis Padgett). |
| | | Catawba 21, Elizabeth City St. 20 |
| | | Daniel Mendez kick attempt good. |
| | | T.Trexler kickoff 56 yards to the ECSU14, Reggie Smith return 86 yards to the CAT0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:07. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 92 yards, TOP 04:31 |
| | | Catawba 21, Elizabeth City St. 13 |
| | | T.Trexler kick attempt good. |
| C | 2-10 | E49 | J.Cuthbertson rush for 49 yards to the ECSU0, 1ST DOWN CAT, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:20. |
| C | 1-10 | E49 | H.Williamson pass incomplete to E.Morman. |
| C | 2-5 | C44 | A.Hall rush for 7 yards to the ECSU49, 1ST DOWN CAT (Lorinzo Lovely;Larry Jones). |
| C | 2-1 | C48 | PENALTY CAT false start 4 yards to the CAT44. |
| C | 1-10 | C39 | H.Williamson pass complete to B.Terwilliger for 9 yards to the CAT48. |
| C | 1-10 | C20 | H.Williamson pass complete to T.Landrum for 19 yards to the CAT39, 1ST DOWN CAT. |
| C | 3-6 | C12 | H.Williamson pass complete to A.Strong for 8 yards to the CAT20, 1ST DOWN CAT (Jeff Lynn). |
| C | 2-7 | C11 | H.Williamson rush for 1 yard to the CAT12, out-of-bounds (Ken Lee), QB hurry by Larry Jones. |
| C | 2-2 | C16 | PENALTY CAT illegal procedure 5 yards to the CAT11. |
| C | 1-10 | C08 | A.Hall rush for 8 yards to the CAT16 (Lorinzo Lovely;Dewitt Dixon). |
| C | 1-10 | C08 | CATAWBA drive start at 07:51 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 58 yards, TOP 02:49 |
| E | 4-1 | C07 | Dennis Hamilton rush for loss of 1 yard to the CAT8 (B.Sutton). |
| E | 4-1 | C07 | Timeout Catawba, clock 07:56. |
| E | 3-21 | C27 | Curtis Rich rush for 20 yards to the CAT7, out-of-bounds (B.Vennable). |
| E | 2-14 | C20 | Curtis Rich sacked for loss of 12 yards to the CAT32 (M.Fair), fumble by Curtis Rich recovered by ECSU Richard Jowers at CAT27. |
| E | 1-10 | C16 | Ricky Hill rush for loss of 4 yards to the CAT20 (C.McAfee). |
| E | 1-10 | E49 | Curtis Rich pass complete to Dexter Manley for 35 yards to the CAT16, 1ST DOWN ECSU, out-of-bounds (T.Jones). |
| E | 3-1 | E43 | PENALTY CAT offside 6 yards to the ECSU49, 1ST DOWN ECSU. |
| E | 2-10 | E34 | Dennis Hamilton rush for 9 yards to the ECSU43 (L.Perry;C.Noel). |
| E | 1-10 | E34 | Curtis Rich pass incomplete to Sean Thomas (T.Jones). |
| E | 1-10 | E34 | ELIZABETH CITY ST. drive start at 10:40 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 41 yards, TOP 02:52 |
| C | 4-5 | E34 | H.Williamson pass incomplete to T.Landrum, dropped pass. |
| C | 3-10 | E39 | H.Williamson pass complete to B.Terwilliger for 5 yards to the ECSU34 (Jeff Lynn;Vitas Berrian). |
| C | 2-10 | E39 | H.Williamson pass incomplete to J.Cuthbertson, QB hurry by Vitas Berrian. |
| C | 1-10 | E39 | J.Cuthbertson rush for no gain to the ECSU39 (Jeff Lynn). |
| C | 2-7 | C28 | J.Cuthbertson rush for 33 yards to the ECSU39, 1ST DOWN CAT (Lorinzo Lovely). |
| C | 1-10 | C25 | A.Hall rush for 3 yards to the CAT28 (T. Williams;Terry Griffin). |
| C | 1-10 | C25 | Timeout Catawba, clock 13:32. |
| C | 1-10 | C25 | CATAWBA drive start at 13:32 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 01:14 |
| E | 4-12 | E30 | Daniel Mendez punt 45 yards to the CAT25, fair catch by A.Strong. |
| E | 3-12 | E30 | Curtis Rich pass incomplete to Sean Thomas. |
| E | 2-10 | E32 | Ricky Hill rush for loss of 2 yards to the ECSU30 (C.McAfee). |
| E | 1-15 | E27 | Dennis Hamilton rush for 5 yards to the ECSU32 (L.Perry). |
| E | 1-10 | E32 | PENALTY ECSU false start 5 yards to the ECSU27. |
| E | 1-10 | E32 | ELIZABETH CITY ST. drive start at 14:46 (2nd). |
| | | T.Trexler kickoff 56 yards to the ECSU14, Reggie Smith return 18 yards to the ECSU32 (EJ Branch). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 12 yards, TOP 01:17 |
| | | Catawba 14, Elizabeth City St. 13 |
| | | T.Trexler kick attempt good. |
| C | 3-12 | E14 | H.Williamson pass complete to B.Bunn for 14 yards to the ECSU0, 1ST DOWN CAT, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:54. |
| C | 3-12 | E14 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |